Cleveland Heights & Greater Cleveland

Heritage
homes,
redefined.

We manage historic homes the way they deserve to be managed — with care, intention, and standards that match the craftsmanship of the homes themselves.

View Available Homes Join the Waitlist

"These homes were built to last a century. We manage them like they'll last another one."

Same-day response

24hr

Maintenance request acknowledgment. Every time.

Security deposit returns

Fair.

Documented, honest, and returned on time. No surprises.

Our Philosophy

Caldwick Homes was built
on one idea.

That the homes in Cleveland Heights, University Heights, and the surrounding neighborhoods deserve better than neglect. They were built with craft and intention — they should be managed the same way.

"Most landlords see an old home and think maintenance headache. I see a 1923 Tudor and get excited. Someone built that well. My job is to keep it that way."

— Jack Caldwick, Founder

Caldwick Homes manages a curated portfolio of heritage properties across Cleveland's east side neighborhoods. We're not the biggest property management company in Cleveland — and we're not trying to be. We're trying to be the best one to live with.

Our properties tend to have waitlists. We think that says everything.

The kitchens are always nice.

Every Caldwick home has quality surfaces and sinks in the kitchen — not granite necessarily, but solid, clean, and chosen with care. It's a small thing that signals everything about how we manage.

You're a member, not a rent check.

We reward tenants who care for their homes and pay on time. Loyalty points, move-in experiences, a wall of fame for departing tenants who left things right. This should feel like belonging somewhere.

Your deposit comes back honestly.

We document everything at move-in and move-out. If you leave the home the way you found it, you get your deposit back. We don't nickel and dime. It's not how we operate.

We take maintenance seriously.

Maintenance requests acknowledged same day. Emergencies handled within hours. If something's broken, we fix it. No runaround, no silence, no excuses.

The Caldwick Standard

What every Caldwick
home comes with.

These aren't aspirations. They're the baseline. Every property, every tenant, every time.

Solid surfaces throughout

Quality countertops and sinks in every kitchen. Not an upgrade — the standard. Because the details matter.

24-hour response

Every maintenance request acknowledged within 24 hours. Emergencies handled same day. No exceptions.

Honest deposit returns

Documented move-in and move-out. Fair assessments. Your money comes back on time when you've earned it.

Loyalty rewards

On-time rent earns points. Long-term residents earn perks. Good tenants are recognized and rewarded.

Transparent accounting

Clear lease terms. No hidden fees. Monthly statements available. We don't hide the ball.

Heritage preserved

We maintain the character of every home. Original details are preserved. These buildings have stories — we keep them going.

Become a Resident

What it takes to live
in a Caldwick home.

We look for residents who take care of their homes, pay on time, and plan to stay a while. In return, we manage the way you'd want to be managed — and we reward loyalty in real dollars.

Qualifications & Screening

We screen every applicant thoroughly and consistently — credit, income, rental history, and background. Our standards are high because our homes deserve residents who'll treat them that way.

The Loyalty Program

On-time rent earns points. Points carry forward forever and convert to gift cards and rent credits. A reliable tenant earns over $1,550 in rewards over 10 years — just for being the kind of tenant they already are.

The Wall of Fame

Residents who return 80% or more of their security deposit earn permanent recognition on our Wall of Fame. Leave the home well and we'll tell the world about it.

A Real Person Answers

hello@caldwick.com goes to a real inbox. Maintenance requests get real responses within 24 hours. You're not dealing with a ticket system and a shrug.

Tenant Qualifications

Review our screening criteria before you apply. We believe in transparency — no surprises.

See qualifications →

Apply for a Home

Our application process is straightforward. A real person reviews every application personally.

Start your application →

Loyalty Program

See exactly how points are earned, what they're worth, and what 10 years of loyalty looks like.

Explore the program →

Frequently Asked Questions

Application timelines, deposits, pets, income verification — the questions we hear most, answered honestly.

Read the FAQ →